Theory of oddness

[RoxasorSora]

Xion has been puzzling me for awhile but I thought of something. What if Kairi had been turned into a heartless when she was young but got her heart back. Causing namines creation (Ive done part of RE:COM and it seems like she was on the island) but when later turned into a heartless created Xion. Well any thoughts suggestions critisisims ill be happy to respond

[GSWarriors]

Who's Xion?

[SacredRiku]

A lot of people think Xion is either Aqua's or Kairi's Nobody which could be true but Kairi turning into a heartless while she was young is a new one. I don't think there would be a way for her to reclaim her heart if she lost it unless the same thing happened when her heart went into Sora. But she already has a Nobody, Namine and i don't think its possible for 1 person to make 2 Nobodies since only 1 person=1 heartless=1 nobody.

[Blak boy playin wit a key]

A lot of people think Xion is either Aqua's or Kairi's Nobody which could be true but Kairi turning into a heartless while she was young is a new one. I don't think there would be a way for her to reclaim her heart if she lost it unless the same thing happened when her heart went into Sora. But she already has a Nobody, Namine and i don't think its possible for 1 person to make 2 Nobodies since only 1 person=1 heartless=1 nobody.

Ehh... for any that dont noe... Xion is the 14th member of Org. XIII/XIV

I completely agree with SR. I really doubt she could reclaim her heart just outta the blue... if she could even lose her heart unwillingly.

As far as we know, until we know about Unbirths, we cant necessarily say that 1 person is a heartless + a nobody. But in theory i gues syou could say that. Now I almost want to apologize for my previous theory lol. Yes there is no way you can have TWO nobodies. Since you cant have two BODIES, and a nobody is your shell without your heart. If i remember right Nomura said Xion is related to a character that hasnt been introduced yet. Because it cant be Aqua's. First of all Aqua is from BBS which is AT LEAST 10 years before 358/2 days. Where Xion is introduced. Second, Ansem the wise is responsible for heartless. So Aqua couldnt have become a heartless, and then a nobody. So Xion cant be Aqua's nobody. And as I mentioned earlier, one cant have TWO nobodies so Kairi cant be it either.

Hope that cleared sum stuff up. Peace :gangsta1:

[lionsbarrage]

what they said is "mostly" true. Except some key facts need to be straightend out.

For one, Kairi could never become a heartless, because she is a princess of heart, which is also why u can possibly form even 1 nobody let alone 2, only because of the help of someone else either Sora or someone else helped in the formation of Namine.


As for Xion we still dont have anything to tie her to anyone but for Aqua. Remember Blak boy Nomura did say the 14th was a character that has been introduced in any of the previous games so far, thats why Aqua coulda and was a prime candidate, now that we know Xion is entirely different there still the case of who she is connected to which is still out in the open. And no Ansem the wise wasnt resposisble for the heartless. The mass infusion of heartless was Xehanorts doing, but even he did not bring the heartless to existence, since the heartless are darkness made real, we dont know how they came to be, but nobodies although fewer woulda have been as well. Also just cause BBS was 10 years ago, doesnt mean Aqua coulda lost her heart then or something happened than, it could be anywhere in between, or she could very well still be alive.

[Yellow Flash]

true....very true........I acctually still think Aqua is alive........

[Key of Valor]

I guess this theory is possible but I doubt
Kairi would lose her heart, get a new body,
and then her Nobody would disappear for
ten years. Not to mention that Kairi is a PoH
and from what has been observed, a PoH
can't produce a Nobody by conventional
means.

I think it is possible for someone to have
two Nobodies but the circumstances for
something like that to happen would be
exceedingly rare.

[soralover223]

Hmm could be, but tetsuya numora said xion has nothing to do with Kairi.
Gswarriors Do your research

[ShadowStorm]

Well, she could have lost her heart in some time during birth by sleep.We all should know that Terra is Sora's dad.(Or Ven is Sora's dad.)
My guess is Ven.Idk D:

[Key of Valor]

Nomura never said that Xion wasn't connected to Kairi.
Xion couldn't have existed in BBS because Heartless and
Nobodies did not exist yet, (possible they did exist but
not in the realm of light) Though it is possible that Terra
is Sora or Ven's dad, it is very unlikely that this is true.
Not to mention there is no reason to believe this nor
proof to suggest it.

[Yellow Flash]

I mean if one of them is his father....who is his mother???
And if Terra was his father, and Terra turned into Xemnes....then Xemnes could say......."Sora I am your father...." Which would be cliche and lame......so I don't think either of them are his father.....or fathers